When beanie babies were first introduced in the early 1990s, they were an instant hit. These adorable little stuffed animals quickly became must-have toy and collectable for kids and adults alike. Thanks to their wide appeal, beanie babies quickly became one of the most successful toy lines in history.
At the height of their popularity, beanie babies were often selling for hundreds or even thousands of dollars each. According to Yahoo, some rarer styles could even fetch prices upwards of $10,000! So, what made these little toys so valuable?
For starters, many people saw beanie babies as collectibles. Unlike other toys that would eventually be outgrown or forgotten about, beanie babies were seen as something that could be kept and enjoyed for years to come. In fact, many people still have their beanie babies from childhood and continue to add to their collections as adults.
Another factor that made beanie babies valuable was their limited availability. During the height of their popularity, Ty Inc., the company that produced beanie babies, would often retire certain styles or discontinue popular characters. This created a sense of urgency among collectors who wanted to get their hands on these rare items before they were gone forever.
Of course, the value of beanie babies eventually declined as their popularity waned in the early 2000s. Today, most beanie babies are worth far less than they once were. However, there are still some rare styles that can command high prices from collectors — many of which we will be highlighting in the full list of rare beanie babies below.
List of the Most Expensive Beanie Babies Ever!
When it comes to beanie babies, the majority of them are only worth a few dollars each these days. However, there are a few that stand out above the rest as the most expensive.
Here’s a look at some of the priciest beanie babies of all time.
1. Princess Diana Bear – $500,000
The first ever Beanie Baby created was the Princess Diana Bear, made in 1997 to commemorate the late Princess of Wales. Only 12 of these bears were ever made, and one was auctioned off for a whopping $500,000 in 2017.
2. Peanut Royal Blue Elephant – $16,000
This rare blue elephant was released in 1995 and is one of the most sought-after Beanie Babies around. There are believed to be less than 100 of these in existence, making it one of the rarest and most expensive Beanie Babies around.
3. Valentino Bear – $15,000
Valentino is another early Beanie Baby, released in 1994. He’s a red bear with a brown nose and is one of the most popular Beanie Babies out there. A mint condition Valentino Bear was sold for $15,000 in 2014.
4. Humphrey Camel – $12,000
Humphrey the Camel was released in 1997 and is one of the more unique-looking Beanie Babies. He has an irregularly-shaped body and this, combined with his rarity, makes him one of the most expensive Beanie Babies around.
5. Garfield The Cat – $10,000
This beanie version of the famous cartoon cat was released in 1999 and is one of the most sought-after Beanie Babies around. He’s got a regular cat’s body but his head is shaped like the cartoon character and he even has Garfield’s signature stripes.
6. Blackie The Cat – $9,000
Blackie the Cat is another rare and sought-after Beanie Baby. He was released in 1997 and is one of the more unique-looking Beanie Babies out there. He’s all black with green eyes and is quite a striking toy.
7. Peking The Panda – $8,500
Peking the Panda was released in 2000 and is one of the most popular Beanie Babies around. He’s an adorable panda bear with black and white fur and is very well-made. He’s also quite rare, making him one of the more expensive Beanie Babies.
8. Spot The Dog – $6,000
Spot the Dog was released in 1996 and is one of the most popular Beanie Babies around. He’s a black and white spotted dog with a bone in his mouth. He’s a well-made toy and is quite rare, making him one of the more expensive Beanie Babies.
9. Claude The Crab – $5,500
Claude the Crab was released in 1998 and is one of the more unique-looking Beanie Babies out there. He’s got a bright red body with blue spots and is quite a striking toy. He’s also quite rare, making him one of the more expensive Beanie Babies.
10. Bones The Dog – $5,000
Bones the Dog was released in 1997 and is one of the most popular Beanie Babies around. He’s a black and white spotted dog with a bone in his mouth. He’s a well-made toy and is quite rare, making him one of the more expensive Beanie Babies.
The Beanie Baby craze might have died down in recent years, but there are still some serious collectors out there. These are the 10 most expensive Beanie Babies of all time.
Where to Find Rare and Expensive Beanie Babies
If you’re a fan of beanie babies, then you know that some of them can be quite valuable. But where can you find rare beanie babies that might be worth a lot of money?
One place to look is online auction sites like eBay. You can often find rare beanie babies being sold by collectors. Another place to check is specialty toy stores. These stores might have rare beanie babies that are hard to find elsewhere.
If you’re lucky enough to find a rare beanie baby, then you could be in for a real treat. These toys can sometimes be worth hundreds or even thousands of dollars. So if you’re a fan of beanie babies, keep your eyes peeled for those rare finds. You never know when you might stumble upon a real treasure.