Best Plush Dog Toys (2026) – Top 10 Reviewed
Plush dog toys provide comfort, entertainment, and mental stimulation for dogs of all sizes. Whether your pup loves to cuddle, play fetch, or engage in a spirited game of tug-of-war, the right plush toy can become their favorite companion.
The best plush dog toys balance durability with softness, feature engaging elements like squeakers and crinkle material, and are sized appropriately for your dog’s chewing style. Here are our top 10 picks for 2026.
| Product | Key Features | Count | Type | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Prime Pets Dog Toys 5 Pack | No stuffing, crinkle, squeaky | 5 | Plush Animals | Best Overall |
| HGB Tough Dog Chew Toys | Bacon flavor, indestructible | 1 | Tough Plush | Best for Aggressive Chewers |
| 20 Pack Puppy Squeaky Toys | Variety pack, squeakers | 20 | Plush Puppies | Best Value |
| Bzonsmart 5 Pack Squeaky Toys | Durable, anti-boredom | 5 | Tough Plush | Best for Teething Puppies |
| HGB Octopus No Stuffing 2 Pack | Crinkle, no stuffing, large | 2 | Octopus Plush | Best for Large Dogs |
| HGB Bunny & Redfox No Stuffing | Squeaky, crinkle, cute designs | 2 | Character Plush | Best for Medium Dogs |
| Emotional Support Pet Fries | Cuddly, gift-worthy | 3 | Novelty Plush | Best Gift Option |
| Emotional Support Pet Nuggies | Soft, comfort toy | 3 | Novelty Plush | Best for Comfort |
| Swooflia Pink Dog Toys 4 Pcs | Squeaky, includes accessories | 4 | Pink Plush Set | Best for Small Dogs |
| Crinkle Squeaky Pink Chick | Tug of war, durable | 1 | Crinkle Plush | Best Budget Option |
1. Prime Pets Dog Toys 5 Pack – Best Overall
Why it stands out: This five-piece set delivers exceptional variety with no-stuffing bodies that eliminate the mess of traditional plush toys while still providing satisfying squeaks and crinkle sounds dogs love.
Each animal in this pack features a flat, no-stuffing design that’s safer for dogs who tend to rip toys apart. The combination of squeakers and crinkle material keeps dogs engaged during play sessions. These toys work well for small, medium, and large breeds, making them versatile for multi-dog households. The animal designs are adorable and each toy offers a different texture experience.
Pros:
- No stuffing means less mess and safer play
- Multiple squeakers and crinkle sounds for engagement
- Five unique animal designs in one pack
- Suitable for all dog sizes
Cons:
- Squeakers may eventually wear out with heavy use
Best for: Dog owners wanting variety and mess-free play in one affordable pack.
2. HGB Tough Dog Chew Toys – Best for Aggressive Chewers
Why it stands out: Designed specifically for dogs who destroy regular plush toys within minutes, this bacon-flavored tough toy combines indestructible materials with the soft feel dogs crave.
The HGB tough chew toy uses reinforced construction that stands up to aggressive chewing while maintaining a plush exterior. The bacon flavor entices even picky dogs to engage with the toy. It’s sized appropriately for large breeds but works for medium dogs too. The squeaker is protected within the durable shell, extending the toy’s lifespan significantly.
Pros:
- Indestructible design for power chewers
- Bacon flavor increases appeal
- Built-in squeaker survives aggressive play
- Reduces boredom and destructive behavior
Cons:
- Higher price point than standard plush toys
Best for: Large breeds and aggressive chewers who typically destroy toys quickly.
3. 20 Pack Puppy Squeaky Dog Toys – Best Value
Why it stands out: With 20 plush puppies in a single pack, this set offers unbeatable value for puppy owners, daycares, or households with multiple dogs who go through toys quickly.
Each toy in this massive pack features a squeaker that small dogs and puppies find irresistible. The cute puppy designs come in various colors and styles, keeping playtime fresh. These are perfectly sized for small dogs and puppies, fitting comfortably in their mouths. At under a dollar per toy, you can rotate through them without worry.
Pros:
- Incredible value with 20 toys
- Perfect size for puppies and small breeds
- Variety of cute designs
- Built-in squeakers in each toy
Cons:
- Not durable enough for aggressive chewers
- Too small for large breeds
Best for: Puppy owners, small dog households, and anyone who wants a large supply of toys on hand.
4. Bzonsmart 5 Pack Squeaky Dog Toys – Best for Teething Puppies
Why it stands out: These tough plush toys are engineered to withstand teething puppies while providing the interactive play that helps redirect chewing behavior to appropriate items.
The Bzonsmart set features reinforced stitching that holds up during the intense chewing phase of puppyhood. Each toy includes multiple squeakers to maintain your puppy’s interest throughout play sessions. The textures help soothe sore gums during teething. These work for small, medium, and large breed puppies, scaling well as your dog grows.
Pros:
- Durable construction for teething puppies
- Five different toy designs
- Multiple squeakers per toy
- Helps redirect destructive chewing
Cons:
- May not survive adult aggressive chewers
Best for: Puppies going through teething who need durable yet soft toys.
5. HGB Octopus No Stuffing 2 Pack – Best for Large Dogs
Why it stands out: These oversized octopus toys feature long tentacles perfect for tug-of-war, no stuffing for safety, and crinkle material throughout for maximum engagement.
Large dogs need large toys, and these octopuses deliver with extended tentacles that are perfect for interactive play. The no-stuffing design means even if your dog manages to tear into it, there’s no fluff scattered around your home. Multiple squeakers are distributed throughout the toy. The crinkle material adds an extra sensory element that keeps big dogs engaged.
Pros:
- Large size appropriate for big breeds
- No stuffing for mess-free play
- Eight tentacles for tug-of-war
- Squeakers and crinkle combined
Cons:
- Only two toys in the pack
Best for: Large breed dogs who love tug-of-war and interactive play sessions.
6. HGB Bunny & Redfox No Stuffing – Best for Medium Dogs
Why it stands out: This adorable two-pack features a bunny and fox with no stuffing, squeakers, and crinkle material—all in a size perfectly suited for medium breeds.
Medium dogs often get overlooked in toy sizing, but these are perfectly proportioned for breeds like Beagles, Bulldogs, and Cocker Spaniels. The cute character designs make them Instagram-worthy while the durable construction handles moderate chewing. The crinkle and squeaky combination provides multiple sound stimuli during play.
Pros:
- Perfect sizing for medium breeds
- Cute bunny and fox designs
- No stuffing construction
- Dual squeaker and crinkle sounds
Cons:
- Only two toys included
Best for: Medium-sized dogs who enjoy cuddling and moderate play sessions.
7. WHAT DO YOU MEME? Emotional Support Pet Fries – Best Gift Option
Why it stands out: These hilarious french fry plush toys combine humor with quality, making them perfect gifts for dog owners who appreciate personality in their pet products.
The Relatable brand has created something special with these emotional support fries—soft, cuddly toys that look adorable in photos and provide genuine comfort to dogs. The three-toy set means plenty of fries to go around. Build quality is surprisingly good for novelty toys, and dogs genuinely seem to love the soft texture.
Pros:
- Hilarious gift for dog owners
- Three toys in the set
- High-quality soft materials
- Instagram-worthy design
Cons:
- Not designed for aggressive chewers
- Novelty pricing
Best for: Gift-giving occasions and dog owners who love unique, personality-filled toys.
8. WHAT DO YOU MEME? Emotional Support Pet Nuggies – Best for Comfort
Why it stands out: These chicken nugget plush toys are designed for dogs who love to cuddle and carry their toys around, providing emotional comfort through soft, squeezable design.
Some dogs don’t want to destroy toys—they want to nurture them. The Emotional Support Nuggies cater to this behavior with ultra-soft construction that’s perfect for dogs who carry toys to bed or around the house. The nugget shapes are perfectly sized for small to medium dogs to hold. Three nuggets mean your dog can have favorites to rotate through.
Pros:
- Ultra-soft comfort design
- Perfect for dogs who carry toys
- Three nuggets included
- Great conversation starter
Cons:
- Will not survive aggressive chewing
- Spot clean only
Best for: Dogs who cuddle with toys rather than destroy them.
9. Swooflia Pink Dog Toys 4 Pcs – Best for Small Dogs
Why it stands out: This pink-themed set includes plush toys plus bonus accessories like a scarf and headband, making it perfect for small dogs whose owners love coordinated accessories.
Small dogs and toy breeds often struggle with oversized toys, but this set is proportioned perfectly for tiny mouths. The squeaky plush toys are soft enough for gentle chewers while the included accessories add photo-op possibilities. The pink color scheme appeals to owners who like coordinated pet products. Note that this set isn’t designed for big or aggressive chewers.
Pros:
- Perfect size for toy breeds
- Includes accessories for photos
- Multiple squeaky toys
- Adorable pink theme
Cons:
- Too small for larger dogs
- Not for aggressive chewers
Best for: Small dogs, toy breeds, and owners who love dressing up their pups.
10. Crinkle Squeaky Dog Toys Pink Chick – Best Budget Option
Why it stands out: This durable single toy offers crinkle material, squeakers, and tug-of-war capability at an entry-level price point that lets you test what your dog enjoys.
Not sure what type of plush toy your dog will love? This pink chick offers multiple play features—crinkle sounds, squeakers, and enough length for tug-of-war—at a price that makes experimentation risk-free. It’s designed for medium dogs and can handle moderate chewing during teething. The cute design is a bonus for owners who want toys that look good lying around.
Pros:
- Affordable entry point
- Multiple engagement features
- Good for tug-of-war
- Cute design
Cons:
- Single toy only
- Medium durability
Best for: Budget-conscious shoppers wanting to test plush toy styles.
How to Choose the Right Plush Toy for Your Dog
Key Features to Look For
The best plush toys combine multiple engagement elements: squeakers that trigger prey drive, crinkle material that adds auditory interest, and textures that feel satisfying in your dog’s mouth. No-stuffing designs have become increasingly popular because they eliminate the mess and choking hazard of traditional stuffed toys.
Size & Breed Considerations
Always match toy size to your dog’s mouth and chewing strength. Small dogs need proportionally smaller toys they can carry comfortably, while large breeds require bigger toys that can’t be swallowed or choked on. Puppies need softer toys during teething, while adult power chewers need reinforced construction.
Durability: Stuffed vs. No-Stuffing
Traditional stuffed toys work well for gentle dogs who cuddle rather than destroy. No-stuffing toys are safer for moderate to aggressive chewers since there’s nothing to ingest if the toy gets torn. For true power chewers, look for toys specifically marketed as “indestructible” with reinforced seams.
What to Avoid
Skip toys with small parts that could be chewed off and swallowed, like plastic eyes or buttons. Avoid toys with long strings or ribbons that pose choking hazards. If a toy starts to fall apart, remove it immediately—ingested stuffing or squeaker parts can cause intestinal blockages.
Signs Your Dog Needs New Toys
- Boredom behaviors: Excessive barking, chewing furniture, or digging indicate your dog needs more mental stimulation through play
- Destroyed current toys: Once toys lose their squeakers or start falling apart, it’s time to replace them
- Loss of interest: Dogs get bored with the same toys; rotating new options keeps them engaged
- Teething puppies: Growing puppies need appropriate chew toys to redirect chewing from furniture and shoes
- Anxiety or stress: Dogs experiencing separation anxiety often benefit from comfort toys they can cuddle
If your dog shows destructive behavior despite having toys, consult with your vet about possible anxiety issues.
Safety Considerations
Plush toys require supervision, especially during initial play sessions. Watch how your dog interacts with new toys—some dogs are cuddlers while others are destroyers. Remove any toy that shows significant wear before pieces can be ingested.
For puppies and aggressive chewers, check toys after each play session for damage. Loose squeakers, torn seams, and exposed stuffing all present choking hazards. When in doubt, throw it out and replace with a fresh toy. Dogs who have swallowed toy parts may show symptoms like vomiting, loss of appetite, or lethargy—contact your vet immediately if you notice these signs.
FAQs
How do I clean plush dog toys?
Most plush toys can be machine washed on gentle cycle with pet-safe detergent, then air dried. Check the label first—some toys are surface wash only. Regular cleaning prevents bacteria buildup and keeps toys smelling fresh.
Are squeakers safe for dogs?
Squeakers are generally safe during supervised play, but they become dangerous if chewed out and swallowed. Choose toys with reinforced squeaker pockets or remove toys once the squeaker is exposed. Dogs who compulsively extract and eat squeakers should use squeaker-free alternatives.
How many plush toys should my dog have?
Most dogs do well with 3-5 toys in rotation, with additional toys stored and swapped out weekly. This keeps toys feeling “new” and prevents boredom. Puppies and high-energy dogs may need more toys available.
Can puppies have plush toys?
Yes, but choose appropriately sized toys without small parts. Teething puppies benefit from softer plush toys that soothe sore gums. Supervise all play and remove damaged toys immediately.
Why does my dog carry plush toys around?
This nurturing behavior is instinctual—many dogs, especially females, treat soft toys like puppies. It’s completely normal and indicates your dog feels comforted by the toy. Provide soft, cuddly toys to satisfy this instinct.
How often should I replace plush toys?
Replace toys when they show significant wear: torn seams, exposed stuffing, missing squeakers, or flattened filling. Most plush toys last 2-4 weeks with active chewers, longer with gentle dogs. Regular inspection prevents accidents.
Final Verdict
The Prime Pets Dog Toys 5 Pack earns our top recommendation for its combination of variety, safety-conscious no-stuffing design, and excellent value. For aggressive chewers, the HGB Tough Dog Chew Toys with bacon flavor provides the durability needed to survive power chewing sessions.
Budget shoppers will love the 20 Pack Puppy Squeaky Toys for unbeatable per-toy value, while those seeking gifts should consider the Emotional Support Pet Fries for their personality and quality. Match your selection to your dog’s size and chewing style for the best results.
